English Ceilidh (ECeilidh)

Home❯Links/Resources❯Classic Texts❯Gender-Free Calling

Gender-Free Calling

This controversial subject gets debated on our forum but we've picked out this contribution from Alan Winston in the USA as it acknowledges several sides of the argument and takes a detailed look at the real issues

Feel free to disregard everything I say, as I am an American and while I occasionally (in non-pandemic times) call barn-dancey things including *very* occasional (once a decade?) ceilidh dances, I'm not in the ceilidh scene.  I'm involved in ECD and contra (cough, cough) and on the board of a Bay Area nonprofit that sponsors (in non-pandemic times) about 20 dances a month plus dance weekends and week-long camps.

1) At last month's board meeting (over Zoom) three self-identified non-binary people I know from dancing - so community members, not outside agitators - talked about the pain and disorientation they feel from being misgendered at dances - by having to sign up to be "man" or "woman" or "gent" or "lady", about other dancers trying to correct the line they were in even if it lined up with how their fluctuating gender identity felt today, etc.  Having seen and for that matter danced in-person with these people, I believe they exist and that they feel harm from gendered calling or exclusion from events that they have to skip to avoid those harms.

[I'm just saying these people exist and feel harm and I am not trying to address anybody's obligation to do anything about that, especially since obligations can be construed as obligations to be welcoming and courteous or legal obligations. I'm not trying to tell you how to balance your obligations to existing stakeholders, need to run profitable and successful events to even keep going, etc, with being welcoming to currently excluded groups, what changes will reduce the quality of experience for incumbents, etc.  Changing *and not changing* both have costs and benefits and the balance between those on any point may be different for each community and person.  So I'm really not trying to tell you what to do or saying you have to do anything different.]

2) "Larks and Ravens" (now "Larks and Robins") was developed specifically for American contra dance in an ongoing series ("Circle Left", here in the SF Bay Area) where you'd expect the majority of attendees - once the series were established - to be regulars.  In modern American contra dance choreography, the vast majority of dances are duple minor improper, and progression is often accomplished via a neighbor swing.  Swings always leave "gent" on the left, "lady" on the right.  The role names were chosen to be reminders: as you line up improper and face your neighbor, Larks are on the Left of their partner, Robins are on the Right of their partner.  When you come out of a swing, Larks are on the Left, Robins are on the Right.)   In calling existing contra dances you can just substitute Lark for Gent, Robin for Lady (and claim that the name of "Ladies Chain" is "Chain" so you say"Robins chain") and bob's your uncle.  This is so true that there's at least one online dance database which will render dance directions with custom role names - it'll show you a card with gents/ladies, larks/robins, whatever.). There are definitely problems in adoption with this: Some people feel juvenilized by bird names.  The Lark/Left Robin/Right association somehow doesn't get across to everybody immediately.  [When it was Larks and Ravens, it seemed that the unconscious association of Larks was female - small, melodious songbirds - and Ravens - larger, squawky- was male, which seemed somewhat misleading but was argued as a positive in breaking the association of gender with role.  I also had one woman complain to me that "Ravens" was an insulting name for women that offended her, not accepting the point that the *point* was that the rolename was meant not to be equivalent to gender.  So it's not a perfect system.  But neither is "gents"/"ladies".  I've heard many calllers use "gent's line" or "lady's line" as landmarks, when, because it's an improper dance, when you start the dance there are equal numbers of gents and ladies in both lines and there's no gender-based visual landmark for that line.     Anyway, it works quite well for the contra-dance use case, and it doesn't really require more ability to deal with left and right than regular contra dancing does.   It also works okay for American squares.  You can force fit it to proper dances ("all the larks are in "this" line" ...) but it's not really designed for that.  There can be some confusion from it but because it's mostly meant for an environment with a lot of returnees individuals can usually get sorted out.  But note that because anyone can be intentionally dancing on any side, experienced people can't tell by looking whether anyone else is in the right place, so a new value of "dance with who's coming at you" has been inculcated in the community.  Pretend whoever you've got knows what they're doing and aremember it's not your job to sort them out.  That calls for more tolerance of muddle, which for some personalities (mine, for example) is difficult.

In the "larks and robins" calling environment. some things don't work as well because you can't rely on visual clues about roles.  A common final figure is "ladies chain, star left to new neighbors", and a fairly common beginner failure is having some muddle about the courtesy turn and starting the star late.  If you're in the next set over and looking at a star that formed late for a new neighbor to balance and swing, you can't tell which of the *four* people in that star is meant for you.  So the wise caller in that environment doesn't call dances with that progression when there are a lot of new dancers present.  It's likelier to break down in truly non-gendered environments.

3) The needs of what in the US we call "one-night stand" dances - your PTA benefits, birthday parties, weddings - are different than those of the dance hobbyist events.  Choosing to call duple minor longways improper dances with swings where it matters what side the swing ends on is malpractice and a waste of everybody's time.  You want to give them something they can do successfully right away, you're not building their skills for subsequent events - there's only tonight, and if you lose them you're not getting them back.  And the last set to form is reluctant, doesn't know left from right, didn't do any earlier dances in the evening, can't hear you clearly, and is drunk.  If they actually don't know anything, they don't know which line the gents should stand in and which line the ladies should stand in; if they're not lined up in the same orientation as other sets they can't copy from them, etc.  Gendered names are possibly helpful if the majority of dancers are in opposite-presentation couples and know which line is supposed to be which, not if they aren't.

4) Whatever calling system you use or environment that's in, you have to pick dances that work for what you're trying to do.  For dance hobbyists who know some stuff (eg, "long first corners") you can for some dances save syllables while keeping or enhancing clarity by using positional terms.  For first-timers who dont' know anything, it's a good idea to do stuff where you don't have to know much more than partner and neighbor.  (I like "Haste to the Wedding" as a Sicilian circle [circle, star, partner do-si-do, clap, two-hand-turn or brief swing; neighbor do-si-do, clap, pass through) because you don't have to know whether you're a one or a two or what side of the set you're on and if you end up on the wrong side of the set you can just carry on.). Some dances developed under a gents-ladies/visual-clue regime won't work as well or at all even if you can render a plausible work around for role names, especially things where partners are doing different things from one another or only one person is doing the thing.

5) A couple of times I've called Regency evenings for almost all-female crowds (Romance Writers of America, and an all-female Austen enthusiast group) and they insisted I call gendered because they wanted the experience of dancing those dances as they would have in the novels (without regard to their not being callers at those dances).  They had no visual clues and I had to remind them with each new dance which line was which, and even though I was choosing simple, symmetrical, and clearly phrased dances there was (well-tolerated and hilarious, possibly because of the wine) muddle on the floor.  Not sure what calling system could have helped a large, tiddly, all-beginner, all-female crowd who'd hired me to do published dances of the Regency era, not dead-simple barn dances.  I got repeat business, so I guess it was okay.

6) Around here, gender-free *is* a selling point to people who feel harm from gendered-role-name calling and to their friends who don't want to feel like they're participating in a discriminatory or exclusionary activity (there are more of the latter than the former; the former are vanishingly few but the only ones we hear from are those who liked country dancing enough to soldier on regardless of felt harm and there might be more of them in a brave new world where the heteronormative association of country dance roles were broken, but there's never going to be that many of them because there aren't that many in the general population - but the latter is highly represented among the young people we need to have our traditions carry on past our own deaths.). So around here, Steve's advice to just work up great gender-free repertoire and calling (good so far!) and never advertising  it as that kind of misses much of the point of doing it (again, around here) , because without advertising it the people who stay away from dances because they'd feel harm from gendered calling don't know it's safe for them to attend, so you're only bringing whatever benefits there are from gender-free calling to the people who need it least.  (Yes, I could tell Steve was being funny.)

Ok, that was long.  Horses for courses.  It's primarily about quickly getting the people on the floor tonight dancing successfully.  While any dance can be forced into any calling system some dances work better than others, and what your current audience is also determines how well your dance is going to work.  If you're going to call gender-free choose dances where that doesn't make it harder.  It's very possible with good choice of dances to do it inconspicuously; substitute role names in ceilidh (making a distinction between that and modern American contra) add a level of translation that makes it harder.
 

Last modified: 23 December 2025, 2:24pm Contact